CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:
C00011

Applies to:
S00823, S00824, S00825, S00826, S00827

Type of request:
Editorial

Request status level:
Resolved

Proposal:
Validation of symbols from IEC 60617-6-5 ... 6 after loading into the database.

Reason:
Transfer of information from the printed publication IEC 60617-6 Ed. 2 into the IEC 60617 datbase.

Requested by:


TC3

General comments:

Comments at evaluation:
Note that the applied symbol S00067 has been corrected: the lower line consists of three dashes to comply with Ed.1 of the IEC 60617.

Comments at validation:
Closing date for validation 1999-12-14.

DE(RESC):The entries for the symbols S00823..827 should be the same in the fields "Shape class" and "Application class"; except S00826 concerning the shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted with regard to shape class. The application class is the same (Circuit diagram) for the symbols except S00826 that is shown for single line representation and therefore got the application classes Overview diageams and Function diagrams.)

JP(HIKE): Add lines and characters to shape class. (Secretary's note: Not accepted. Only the two most predominant shape classes indicated.)

JP(HIKE): For S00825, lines, characters and squares should be added to shape class. (Secretary's note: Not accepted. Only the two most predominant shape classes indicated.)

JP(HIKE): For S00826, we have two oblique strokes. Thus, it is an application of S00001, not S00002. (Secretary's note: Formally correct and changed, but a reference to S00002 would be better provided that this symbol had a more generalized description.)

FR(FCOD): For S00826, Function class FR: read : de même nature (Secretary's note: Introduced as a general list modification.)

Voting at validation:
DE(RESC): Symbols S00823..S00827: YES; please refer to my comment.
AT(WGAS): Symbols S00823 - S00827: Yes
FI(TAVI): Symbols S00823 - S00827: Yes, Agreed with DE(RESC) comment.
JP(HIKE): Symbol S00826: NO; Symbols S00823...S00825 and S00827: YES
FR(FCOD): Symbols S00823 - S00827: Yes

Result: The change request is approved. The symbols will be released with modifications as above.

Requested on:
1999-11-18

Evaluated on:
1999-11-18

Resolved on:
1999-12-17

Withdrawn on:

Evaluation closing on:

Validation closing on: