IEC 60617 - Graphical Symbols for Diagrams

CHANGE REQUEST
Request identity number:	C00012
Applies to:	S01185, S01186, S01187, S01188, S01189, S01190, S01191, S01192, S01193, S01194, S01195, S01196, S01197, S01198, S01199, S01200, S01201, S01202, S01203, S01204, S01205, S01206, S01207, S01208, S01209, S01210, S01211
Type of request:	Editorial
Request status level:	Resolved
Proposal:	Validation of IEC 60617-10-09 ... 10 after loading into the database.
Reason:	Transfer of information from the printed publication IEC 60617-10 Ed. 2 into the IEC 60617 datbase.
Requested by:	TC3
General comments:
Comments at evaluation:	No comments.
Comments at validation:	Closing date for validation 2000-02-11 JP(HIKE): Graphical symbols under validation by C00012 fall within the technical area of "Transmission in telecommunication; Microwave technology; Multi-port devices (for 10-09-xx) and couplers and probes (for 10-10-xx)." Therefore, these words should be in keywords field of each graphical symbols. (Secretary's note: multi-port devices (microwave), microwave devices, couplers, probes added.) JP(HIKE: S01185 would be an example of S00001. (Secreatary's note: Accepted.) JP(HIKE)+DK(KATH): Add "character" in shape classes of S01186...S01188. (Secreatary's note: Accepted.) DK(KATH): For S01195 and S01199 add "character" in shape class. (Secreatary's note: Accepted.) JP(HIKE)+DK(KATH): Add "character" in chape classes of S01191...S01194. (Secreatary's note: Accepted.) JP(HIKE): For S01196, S00095 instead of S00096 should be cited in "is an application of." (Secreatary's note: Accepted.) JP(HIKE): For S01196...S01199, add "line" to shape class. (Secreatary's note: Not accepted.) JP(HIKE): For S01198, S00583 is cited but the winding of S01198 is consist of 3-half-circles. This will be aligned by a separate change request. (Secreatary's note: An application note should be added to S00583 that the number of half-circles should be added to suite the circumstances. Added to C00024.) FI(TAVI): Add note to S01198 " In spcial cases the number of half-circles can be smaller than four." (Secretary's note: Covered by C00024.) JP(HIKE)+DK(KATH): For S01200, add "line" to shape class; it is not half-circle, but a part of circle. (Secretary's note: "Circle segment" added as entry. "Line" not added.) JP(HIKE)+DK(KATH): For S01201, add "part of circle" to shape class. (Secretary's note: "Circle segments" added.) JP(HIKE): For S01201, part of circle instead of half-circle in shape class; is it an example of S01200? (Secretary's note: "Circle segments" added.It might be seen as an example, but it might not be evident to everybody, no change.) JP(HIKE): For S01200...S1202, these are the examples of S00017(03-02-02). (Secretary's note: Accepted.) DK(KATH): For S01202 add "part of circle" to shape class. (Secretary's note: "Circle segments" added.) JP(HIKE): For S01204, add S01172 to "is an exmple of" field; change "circle" to "part of circle" in shape class; there are several examples to be added such as S00751 and S00754. (Secretary's note: S01172 added, "circle segments" added, added as application of in S00753 and S00754.) DK(KATH): For S01204 add "dots" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.) JP(HIKE)+DK(KATH): For S01207, add "line" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.) JP(HIKE)+DK(KATH): For S01208, add "line" and "character" to shape class. (Secretary's note: "Character" added.) JP(HIKE): For S01209, add S00737 to applications; add "line" to shape class. (Added in the meantime.) JP(HIKE) and DE(RESC): For S01210, delete S01210's from "examples" and "is an application of" fields; add S01209 and S01211 to "examples". (Secretary's note: Ref to S01210 deleted. S01211 refers to S01210.) DK(KATH): For S01211 add "arrows" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.) JP(JIKE): Is S01198 an example of S01197? (Secretary's note: Close enough to motivate the reference.) FR(FCOD): S00185 keywords FR read (hyperfréquences);Keywords(EN)read: "connexions"; Application class (FR), read: "Tous types de schémas" DE(RESC): For S01189: add "circuit diagrams" for the application class DE(RESC): For S01190: for the shape class, it might be better to change "right angle triangel" to "triangel" only. See also application note A00136, concerning the angles, and refer to S001193,1195 and 1195 "right angle " and "equilateral angel" (Secretary's note: Changed to "equilateral triangles" in all places. The distinction between right-angled and equilateral triangles is relevant for may other symbols and therefore maintained.) DE(RESC): For S01198: add W and X to the application class, as for S01197 (Secretary's note: They were there - technical error.)
Voting at validation:	Closing date for validation: 2000-02-11. JP(HIKE): Symbols S01196, S01204, S01209, S01210: NO JP(HIKE): The rest of symbols: YES DE(RESC): Symbols S01185 to S01211: YES with comments AT(WGAS):Symbols S01185 - S01211: Yes FI(TAVI): Symbols S01185 - S01211: Yes DK(KATH): Symbols S01185 - S01211: Yes with comments Result: The change request is approved with the modifications done. The symbols will be released
Requested on:	1999-11-29
Evaluated on:	1999-11-29
Resolved on:	2000-03-06
Withdrawn on:
Evaluation closing on:
Validation closing on: