CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:

C00013

Applies to:

S01212, S01213, S01214, S01215, S01216, S01217, S01218, S01219, S01220, S01221, S01222, S01223, S01224, S01225, S01226, S01227, S01228, S01229, S01230, S01231, S01232, S01233, S01234, S01235, S01236, S01237, S01238

Type of request:

Editorial

Request status level:

Resolved

Proposal:

Validation of symbols from IEC 60617-10-11 ... 14 after loading into the database.

Reason:

Transfer of information from the printed publication IEC 60617-10 Ed. 2 into the IEC 60617 datbase.

Requested by:



TC3

General comments:


Comments at evaluation:

No comments.

Comments at validation:

Closing date for validation

JP(HIKE): Symbols S01212...S01217 are applicable to the technical area of transmission in telecommunication; Microwave technology; masers and lasers. Therefore, these words should appear in "keywords" fields. (Secretary's note: "masers" and "lasers" are included, the other proposals appear to be too wide. There are a number of other symbols relevant for these keywords, in other parts, but they are not marked.)

JP(HIKE): Symbols S01218...S01224 are applicable to the technical area of transmission in telecommunication; Pulse modulation. Therefore, these words should appear in respective keywords fileds. (Secretary's note: "pulse modulation - types of" is included, for the others, see above.)

JP(HIKE): Symbols S01225...S01230 are originally applicable to the technical area of transmission in telecommunication; signal generator. Therefore, these words should appear in respective keywords fields. (Secretary's note: "signal generators" is included, for the others, see above.)

JP(HIKE): For symbols S01212, S01215-S01216-S01217 should also be added to "applications." (Secretary's note: Not accepted. S001212 and S01214 are different concepts, although the symbols look related.)

JP(HIKE): For symbols S01212...S01217, add "lines" to shape classes. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For symbol S01215, add S01216 and S01217 as examples.(Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For symbol S01216 and S01217, add "character" to shape classes; A00040 should be cited to qualify the symbols by characteres. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For symbol S01225, add S01226 to application. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For S01218, the keywords should includes "pulse-modulation, position, phase". "pulse modulation - types of" does not name specifically. (Secretary's note: Not accepted, "pule modulation - types of" is intended to cover all kinds, in order to reduce the number of keywords.)

JP(HIKE): For S01224, rename "pulse-code modulation in 3-out-of-7 code"; add "character" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For S01220, keywords should be improved. (Secretary's note: The existing keyword is kept for the same reason as above.)

JP(HIKE): For S01223, delete S01323 from example. It is an error. Add "PCM" to keywords. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For S01225, add S00059 to "is application of" together with A00013; "character" should be added to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For S01226, add depicting shape, line, and character to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For S01227, add line to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For S01228, add character and line to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For S01230, add character and line to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For S01237, add depicting shape to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DE(RESC): For S01213: add function class "E" and "T". (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DE(RESC): For S01215 and S01217: add function class "E" and "G". (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For S01215 add A00138 as application note and add "characters" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For S01216, S01217, S01225, S01227....S01230 add "characters" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For S01224 delete A00141 as application note and add "characters" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For S01226 add "depicting shape" and "characters" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For S01232....S01234 and S01236 add "characters" and "lines" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For S01235 and S01238 add "lines" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For S01237 add "depicting shape", "lines" and "characters" to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

Voting at validation:

JP(HIKE): Symbols S01212-S01215-S01216: NO
JP(HIKE): Symbols S01213-S01214-S01217: YES
JP(HIKE): Symbol S01218: NO
JP(HIKE): Symbol S01223: NO
JP(HIKE): Symbol S01224: NO
JP(HIKE): Symbol S01225: NO
JP(HIKE): Symbols S01219...S01222: YES
JP(HIKE): Symbols S01226...S01230: YES
JP(HIKE): Symbols S01231...S01238: YES
DE(RESC): Symbols S01212 to S01238: YES, with comments
AT(WGAS): Symbols S0212 - S01238: Yes
FI(TAVI): Symbols S01212 - S01238: Yes
DK(KATH): Symbols S01212 to S01238: YES, with comments.

The symbols have been released with changes as noted above.

Requested on:

1999-11-29

Evaluated on:

1999-11-29

Resolved on:

2000-06-22

Withdrawn on:


Evaluation closing on:


Validation closing on: