CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:
C00015

Applies to:
S00841, S00842, S00843, S00844, S00845, S00846, S00847, S00848, S00849, S00850, S00851, S01343, S01344

Type of request:
Editorial

Request status level:
Resolved

Proposal:
Validation of symbols from IEC 60617-6-9 after loading into the database.

Reason:
Transfer of information from the printed publication IEC 60617-6 Ed. 2 into the IEC 60617 datbase.

Requested by:


TC3

General comments:

Comments at evaluation:
Old symbol numbers 06-09-10 (S00850) and 06-09-11 (S00851) have been duplicated (S01343, S01344), since they cover two concepts.

Comments at validation:
Closing date for validation 1999-12-31.

JP(HIKE): Symbols S00841...S00851 are in the technical field of "production and conversion of electrical enery." Thus these words should be included in keywords. (Secretary's note. Not accepted, see C00014.)

JP(HIKE)+ DK(KATH): For symbols S00841...S00851, add "lines" to shape class. (Secretary's note. Not accepted, see C00014.)

JP(HIKE): For symbol S00844, delete S00882 from "examples." (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For symbol S00848, replace S00849 with S00583 and delete S00849, becaue S00849 is the same as S00583. (Secretary's note: S00583 and S00849 are graphically the same, but do not represent identical concepts. Not accepted.)

JP(HIKE)+ DK(KATH)+ FI(TAVI): Symbols S01343 and S01344 should be deleted, because they are covered by S00850 and S00851, respectively. (Secretary's note: Not accepted because the concepts are not identical.)

AT(WGAS): In case of S00841,842 the name "form 1 and 2" in the application and description note should be changed to the symbol-ID. Form 1 and 2 is only in the printed version of 60617 visible. (Secretary's note: The forms 1 and 2 are defined also in the database. It is necessary to use the terms in the note since it applies to many symbols, see the list in the application note. Not accepted.)
S00850 and851 is equal with S001343 and1344. (See observation above.)

DK(KATH): For symbol S00841 delete S00876 from examples. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For symbol S00842 delete S01344 from examples. (Secretary's note: Not accepted - it is a consequence of keeping S01344.)

DK(KATH): The text in "name and usage" for S00843 has to be changed in between and A00129 may be added as an application note. (Secretary's note: The name modified to cover both: Transformer with two windings (and instantaneous voltage polarity indicators). A00129 will be added.)

DK(KATH): In symbol S00849 add to remark: The graphic is identical with the graphic used in symbol S00583. Secretary's note: This is included by "Applying:".)

DK(KATH): In symbol S00847 add to remark: The graphic is identical with the graphic used in symbol S00571. Secretary's note: Do not understand reference to 571, I guess it should be 583: if so: This is included by "Applying:".)

DK(KATH)+ FI(TAVI): I can't see the meaning with the symbol S01343 and S01344 yet! (Secretary's note: They do not represent identical concepts with S00850 and S00851.)

FI(TAVI): Is it possible to add to Usage of S00841 and S00842: General symbol (Secretary's note: Actually the whole section 9 is labeled "general symbols" so I have added that to symbols S008841 to S00851.)

Voting at validation:
JP(HIKE): Symbol S00844: NO (see comment).
JP(HIKE): Symbol S00848: NO (see comment).
JP(HIKE): Symbols S01343 and S01344: NO.
JP(HIKE): Symbols S00841...S00843, S00845...S00847, S00849...S00851: YES
AT(WGAS): S00841 - S00851 and S001342,S001344: Yes (see also comments)
DK(KATH)+FI(TAVI): Symbols S00841...S00851: Yes (see also comments)
DK(KATH)+FI(TAVI): symbols S01343 and S01344: No (see comment) (Secretary's note: changed to YES by e-mail)
DK(KATH): symbols S01343 and S01344: YES (after explanation of the meaning)

Result: The change request is approved. The symbols will be released with modifications as above.

Requested on:
1999-12-08

Evaluated on:
1999-12-08

Resolved on:
2000-01-13

Withdrawn on:

Evaluation closing on:

Validation closing on: