CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:
C00016

Applies to:
S00852, S00853, S00854, S00855, S00856, S00857, S00858, S00859, S00860, S00861, S00862, S00863, S00864, S00865, S00866, S00867, S00868, S00869, S00870, S00871, S00872, S00873, S00874, S00875, S00876, S00877

Type of request:
Editorial

Request status level:
Resolved

Proposal:
Validation of symbols from IEC 60617-6-10 ... 12 after loading into the database.

Reason:
Transfer of information from the printed publication IEC 60617-6 Ed. 2 into the IEC 60617 datbase.

Requested by:


TC3

General comments:

Comments at evaluation:
No comments.

Comments at validation:
Closing date for validation 1999-12-31.

JP(HIKE): Symbols S00852...S869 are for "separate widing" transformers in the category of qualifying symbols winding interconnections in the field of "production and conversion of electrical energy." Thus, these words should be included in such as common keywords. (Secretary's note: "transformers with separate windings" , will be included as keyword.)

JP(HIKE): For symbols S00854...S00869, add lines to shape class as in S00852. (Secretary's note: Line added to S00854, 856, 858, 860, 861, 862, 864, 866.)

JP(HIKE)+FI(TAVI): For symbol S00855, delete S00002 from "is an example of." (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For symbols S00860 and S00862, add characters to shape class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HIKE): For symbol S00871, S00847 is referred to as "an example of", however they are exactly the same symbol! Therefore, both should have the same S-number and amended to be a single entry to the database. - Please regard this future work. (Secretary's note: Kept as it is for the time being. To be considered later, see C0024.)

JP(HIKE)+FI(TAVI): For symbol S00874, add S00870 to "is an example of". (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For symbols S00854...S00877, add lines to shape class as in S00852 and S00853. (Secretary's note: See observation above. Additionally added to S00870, 872, 874, 876.)

DK(KATH): In symbol S00854 delete the A00129 from "Application notes". (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): In symbol S00856 add variability in Keywords. (Secretary's note: accepted.)

DK(KATH): In symbols S00864 and S00865 is the remark a part of the name! (Secretary's note: The type of connection is not relevant for searching purposes. The full text is kept in the remark. No change.)

DK(KATH): In symbols S00871 and S00875 add A00130 in the "Application notes". (Secretary's note: A0130 is not technically applicable for an autotransformer - there is only one possibility. No change.)

DK(KATH): The symbol S00876 is a "very special example" of the symbol S00841. I don't like this connection, and by the way, is "T" the function class for this symbol? (Secretary's note: S00841 deleted as example. Function class changed to R.)

Voting at validation:
JP(HIKE)+FI(TAVI): Symbol S00855: NO (see comment)
JP(HIKE)+FI(TAVI): Symbols S00852...S00869, except S00855: YES
JP(HIKE)FI(TAVI): Symbol S00874: NO (see comment)
JP(HIKE)´+FI(TAVI): Symbols S00870...S00877, except S00874: YES
AT(WGAS): Symbols S00852 - S00877: Yes
DK(KATH): Symbols S00852 - S00877: Yes, but see the comments!

Result: The change request is approved with the modifications done. The symbols will be released.

Requested on:
1999-12-08

Evaluated on:
1999-12-08

Resolved on:
2000-01-13

Withdrawn on:

Evaluation closing on:

Validation closing on: