CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:
C00017

Applies to:
S00878, S00879, S00880, S00881, S00882, S00883, S00884, S00885, S00886, S00887, S00888, S00889, S00890, S00891

Type of request:
Editorial

Request status level:
Resolved

Proposal:
Validation of symbols from IEC 60617-6-13 after loading into the database.

Reason:
Transfer of information from the printed publication IEC 60617-6 Ed. 2 into the IEC 60617 database.

Requested by:


TC3

General comments:

Comments at evaluation:
No comments.

Comments at validation:
Closing date for validation 1999-12-31.

JP(HIKE)+ DK(KATH): For symbol S00878, S00975 listed as an example of application, however, S00975 should be an example of S00841, but not an example of (signal) voltage transformer S00878. (Secretary's note: Accepted. The usage of S00878 is "measuring transformer", and this is not applicable for a transformer that drives a signal lamp (S00975). Changed in S00975.)

FI(TAVI): Note S00975 is example of both S00878 and S00841. (Secretary's note: See comment above.)

JP(HIKE): For symbol S00882, "In form 2, the core symbol shall be drawn" should appear in Remark(s). (Secretary's note: Not accepted, since the actual symbol is a form 1 symbol. The application note appears in form 2 of it.)

JP(HIKE)+ DK(KATH): Symbol S00888 refers to S00003 named "three connections", but the name should also include "three conductors" in line with its usage here (this is not the comment to S00888, but to S00003). (Secretary's note: The names of symbols S00002 and S00003 (not yet validated) have been generalized to take account of this comment.)

JP(HIKE): Symbol S00889 points S00904 as an example, but it is irrelevant and deleted. An example of S00889 will be S00891(?) (Secretary's note: Accepted: S00904 deleted.)

DK(KATH): Symbol S00889 points S00904 as an example - by mistake I suppose, that is wrong. (Secretary's note: See above.)

DK(KATH): In symbol S00885 add A00127 in "Application notes". (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): In A00134 delete S01343 and S01344 as reference (see also comments in C00015). (Secretary's note: Not accepted. These symbols are kept.)

DE(RESC): Table 1 of IEC 61346-2 calls for the application class "T" for voltage and current transformers. I can imagine, tthat there are some good reasons to change to "B", but at the moment it is still "T"

Voting at validation:
JP(HIKE): Symbol S00878: NO
JP(HIKE): Symbol S00889: NO
JP(HIKE): Symbols S00879...S00887, S00890, S00891: YES
AT(WGAS): Symbols S00878 - S00891: Yes
DK(KATH): Symbols S00878 - S00891: Yes (see also comments)
FI(TAVI): Yes
DE(RESC): NO

Result: The change request is approved with the modifications done. The symbols will be released.

Requested on:
1999-12-10

Evaluated on:
1999-12-10

Resolved on:
2000-01-14

Withdrawn on:

Evaluation closing on:

Validation closing on: