CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:
C00020

Applies to:
S00001, S00002, S00003, S00004, S00005, S00006, S00007, S00008, S00009, S00010, S00011, S00012, S00013, S00014, S00015, S00058

Type of request:
Editorial

Request status level:
Resolved

Proposal:
Validation of IEC 60617-03-01 after loading into the database.

Reason:
Transfer of information from the printed publication IEC 60617-03 Ed. 2 into the IEC 60617 database.

Requested by:


TC3

General comments:

Comments at evaluation:
The names of symbol S00002 and S00003 have been generalised in order to make these symbols easier to refer to.

Symbols S00007, S00008, S00009 and S00010 form originally a rather complex structure with regard to the application note. In order to resolve it the application note now deviates slightly from the original one.

Comments at validation:
Closing date for validation 2000-01-21.

DE(RESC): Delete symbol S00058 and add a second name to the original symbol S00001. (Secretary's note: S00001 and S00058 are two concepts using the same graphical representation. No change.)

DE(RESC): With symbol S00001 i miss the application note A00192. (Secretary's note: This note speaks about a group of connections and can therefore not apply to S00001. It applies to S00058 only.)

JP(HYAM): For symbols S00002, 3 and 58, the description that is the same as A00194 should be deleted from A00192. (Secretary's note: The sentence will be deleted from A00192. A00194 will be modified to cover connections as well as group of connections.)

JP(HYAM): For symbols S00003, 4, add "Characters" to Shape Class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HYAM)+DK(KATH): For symbols S00009, 10, 13 add "Lines" to Shape Class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HYAM): For symbols S00009, 10, in Shape Class, "Half-circles" and "Lines" to be more suitable than "Ellipses". (Secretary's note: We are missing a suitable term for these kinds of shapes. I add "half-circles" and "lines".)

JP(HYAM): For symbols S00009, 10, 14, 15, add "cable" to Keyword (s). (Secretary's note: Accepted. "cables" added also to S00001.)

AT(WGAS): S00001 and S00058 are equal. (Secretary's note: See comment above.)

Voting at validation:
FI(TAVI): Symbols S00001 - S00015 and S00058: Yes
DE(RESC): Symbols S00002-S000015: YES; Symbols S00001 and S00058: NO
JP(HYAM): Symbols S00001 - S00015 and S00058: Yes, see "Comments at validation".
AT(WGAS): Symbols S00001 - S00015 and S00058: Yes See also comments of validaiton
DK(KATH): Symbols S00001 - S00015 and S00058: YES, but see comments.

Result: The change request is approved with the modifications done. The symbols will be released.

Requested on:
2000-01-04

Evaluated on:
2000-01-04

Resolved on:
2000-01-26

Withdrawn on:

Evaluation closing on:

Validation closing on: