CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:
C00022

Applies to:
S00031, S00032, S00033, S00034, S00035, S00036, S00037, S00038, S00039, S00040, S00041, S00042, S00043, S00044, S00045, S00046, S00047, S00048, S00049

Type of request:
Editorial

Request status level:
Resolved

Proposal:
Validation of IEC 60617-03-03 after loading into the database.

Reason:
Transfer of information from the printed publication IEC 60617-03 Ed. 2 into the IEC 60617 datbase.

Requested by:


TC3

General comments:

Comments at evaluation:
There is a difference in symbol sizes among S00031 and S00032 compared to S00047 ... S00049, and in S00042 compared to S00011. This ought to be corrected and we should file a change request for it, unless this is not already included in the "task II" works.

Comments at validation:
Closing for validation 2000-01-21.

DE(RESC): With symbol S00033, the link to the appl. notes A0006 and 7 might be misleading. Wouldn't it be better just to make a remark, that the rules of the symbols S00031 and 32 apply? (Secretary's note: A new combined note A00210 replaces the old ones.)

JP(HYAM): For symbol S00034, in Application class, change "Circuit diagrams" to "All kinds of diagrams". (Secretary's note: Symbols that can be used in both multi-line and single-line representation are classified as usable in "all kinds of diagrams". In this case the symbol is in multi-line representation and therefore its use is likely to be "circuit diagrams". No change.)

JP(HYAM): For symbol S00035, add "Characters" to Shape Class. (Accepted.)

JP(HYAM): For symbol S00037, this symbol's shape is not Rectangle strictly, though Rectangles is in Shape Class. (Secretary's note:Correct observation, but there is no better class available.)

JP(HYAM): For symbol S00038, add the contents of S00037's Shape Class and "Half-circles" to Shape Class. (Secretary's note: Half-circles added.)

JP(HYAM)+DK(KATH): For symbols S00039-40, add "Circles" and "Lines" to Shape Class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HYAM): For symbol S00041, 44, 46, add "Circles" to Shape Class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HYAM)+DK(KATH): For symbol S00042, add "Lines" to Shape Class. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

JP(HYAM): Add the next keyword(s) respectively. "socket" to S00031, 33 - 35, 42, "plug" to S00032 - 35, 39 - 40, 42, 47, 49, "jack" to S00039-40, "connector" to S00036 - 38, 43, 47. (Secretary's note: Accepted.)

DK(KATH): For symbol S00041 add "Circles" to Shape Class.

DK(KATH): I agree with the "comments at validation", and I will prefer an application note as an combination of A00006 and A00007 to symbol S00033. (See above.)

Voting at validation:
DE(RESC): Symbols S00031 - S00048: YES ( but see comment above)
JP(HYAM): Symbols S00031 - S00048: Yes, see "Comments at validation".
AT(WGAS): Symbols S00031 - S00049: Yes
FI(TAVI): Symbols S00031 - S00049: Yes
DK(KATH): Symbols S00031 - S00049: YES, but see comments.

Result: The change request is approved with the modifications done. The symbols will be released.

Requested on:
2000-01-05

Evaluated on:
2000-01-05

Resolved on:
2000-01-27

Withdrawn on:

Evaluation closing on:

Validation closing on: