CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:
C00053

Applies to:
S00434, S00436, S00437, S01334, S01336, S01340

Type of request:
Editorial

Request status level:
Resolved

Proposal:
The symbols S00434 and S01334 are identical, only the context is different. They should be harmonized, and one deleted.

This applies also to S00437 and S01336, and S00436 and S01340.

Withdraw symbols S00434, S00436 and 437 and add the keywords for these symbols to S01334, S01336 and S01340 respectively.

Reason:
Duplication. This is also part of the Task II proposal for Part 10.

Requested by:
TC3 Secretary
per-ake.svensson@iec.ch
TC3

General comments:

Comments at evaluation:
Submitted for evaluation 2002-03-04. Closing date for evaluation 2002-04-30.

NO(ES): The symbols S00434 and S00437 are spesific usage of the general symbols S01334 and S01336 respectively. They could be deleted if their usage could be given as usage of their eneral symbol respectively.

DE(RESC): I agree for the normal data base procedure.

AT(WGAS): I agree with the proposal. What is the proposal for symbol S00435 and S01335?

JP(HIKE): We agree to the proposal and suggest to apply the normal database procedure for vote.

DK(KATH): We agree with the proposals using normal database procedure, but what about S00435 and S01335 ?? (Comment by the Secretary: They seem to have been linked by mistake. Generally, i try to link all affected symbols, including redirection of their links, and that might be difficult to discover. However, also the links seem to be correct in this case. The links have been taken away.)

Conclusion by the Secretary: The change request will be submitted for validation, with the addition the names of S00434 and S00437 will be added as usage of S01334 and S01336.

Comments at validation:

Voting at validation:
NO(ES): Delete S00434 ansd S00437. Modify S01334 and S01336 with indication in the usage field the spesific meaning of S00434 and S00437 respectively.

AT(WGAS): Yes to harmonize S00434 and S01334,S00437 and S01336, S00436 and S01340. Yes to withdraw symbols S00434, S00436 and S00437.

DK(KATH): Yes to harmonize S00434 and S01334, S00437 and S01336, S00436 and S01340. After that the symbols S00434, S00436 and S00437 can be withdrawn.

DE(RESC): We agree to withdraw symbols S00434, S00436 and 437 and to add the keywords for these symbols to S01334, S01336 and S01340 respectively.

JP(HIKE): Yes to the conclusion by the Secretary.

Conclusion by the Secretary: The proposal is approved and will be implemented.

Requested on:
2001-03-14

Evaluated on:
2002-05-01

Resolved on:
2002-07-04

Withdrawn on:

Evaluation closing on:
2002-04-30

Validation closing on:
2002-06-30