CHANGE REQUEST
Request identity number:
C00063
Applies to:
S00212
Type of request:
Editorial
Request status level:
Resolved
Proposal:
Delete the application example with an electron tube in application note A00250, which is referenced from S00212.
It is considered as obsolete.
Reason:
This proposal is part of the Task II work for IEC 60617-2.
Requested by:
TC3
General comments:
Comments at evaluation:
Closing date for evaluation 2001-09-14.
NO(ES): Just deleting the example in the application note A00250 is not enough. The complete note could be deleted.
FI(TAVI): I like the note to be retained. In addition there could be reference to IEC 61082-1 Clause x and IEC 61346. See IEC 61082-1 clause 4.7.1.
AT(WGAS): Agree to the proposal. Electron tubes are no more in use.
Conclusion by the Secretary: The opinions are different with regard to the need for the example: from taking away the application note completely to retaining and extend it.
IEC 61082 applies the basic standard IEC 60617. It is therefore quite in order to make references to IEC 60617 from IEC 61082, but it would create future maintenance problems to make references to specific clauses in the other direction.
Therefore I think that a good compromise would be stick to keep the original propsal. The proposal in its original form is therefore submitted for validation in acccordance with the simplified procedure.
Comments at validation:
Submitted for validation 2001-09-15. Closing date for validation 2001-10-12.
Voting at validation:
DE(RESC): Yes for the original proposal.
NL(MIBO): Yes
NO(ES): Yes
AT(WGAS): Yes
DK(KATH): Yes
Conclusion by the Secretary: The proposal is approved and the application note will be changed.
Requested on:
2001-07-21
Evaluated on:
2001-09-15
Resolved on:
2001-10-13
Withdrawn on:
Evaluation closing on:
Validation closing on: