CHANGE REQUEST |
Request identity number: |
C00090 |
Applies to: |
S01239, S01241, S01242, S01243 |
Type of request: |
Editorial |
Request status level: |
Resolved |
Proposal: |
Withdraw the listed symbols.
Note that the first of these is one of the forms for amplifiers, with a very large number of applications elsewhere in the standard.
|
Reason: |
This is part of the Task II proposal for Part 10.
For reference please refer to the attached document.
|
Requested by: |
TC3 Secretary
per-ake.svensson@se.abb.com
TC3 |
General comments: |
|
Comments at evaluation: |
Submitted for evaluation 2002-02-26. Evaluation closing 2002-04-26. Extension until 2002-04-30.
DE(RESC): I agree for the normal database procedure.
AT(WGAS): I agree to the proposal to withdraw the listed symbols.
CN(GUTI):I agree the proposal to withdraw the above symbols.
JP(HIKE): We are aware of the note above for the first symbol. Nevertheless, within IEC 60617 database, we should admit it is special. Because of S01239 being used, let us propose the withdrawal of S01239 (only) for vote in the extended procedure.
FI(TAVI): I propose that the use of triangle as qualifying symbol inside of rectangles like in IEC 60617 12-09-08A, -08B, IEC 60617 section 29 and IEC 60617 sections 8 and 9 should be taken into account so that triangle should be stated as qualifying symbol. See also e.g. S01213. I propose the modification of S01239 (only) for vote in the extended procedure.
DK(KATH): We agree to the proposal using extended procedure for S01239 and normal database procedure for the rest.
Conclusion by the Secretary: The symbols S01241, S01242 and S01243 will be submitted for validation in acordance with the normal database procedure.
Because of the large number of applications of symbol S01239, the proosal to withdraw that one will be dealt with in accordance with the extended procedure. |
Comments at validation: |
Symbols S01241, S01242 and S01243 are submitted for validation 2002-05-28.
The proposal for S01239 is processed in accordance with the extended database procedure, document 3/604/CDV. |
Voting at validation: |
AT(WGAS): Yes to withdraw symbols S01241, S01242 and S01243.
DK(KATH): Yes to the withdrawal of the symbols S01241, S01242 and S01243.
FI(TAVI): Yes to the withdrawal of the symbols S01241, S01242 and S01243.
DE(RESC): Yes to withdraw symbols S01241, S01242 and S01243.
JP(HIKE): Yes.
CN(GUTI): Yes.
Conclusion by the Secretary: The withdrawal of the symbols S01241, S01242 ans S01243 is approved and will be implemented. The CR is by this partly resolved 2002-08-04.
------------
Comments 2002-12-02 by the Seccretary:
Document 3/604/CDV was rejected, see document 3/653//RVC.
This Change request is by this considered finally resolved.
A modified proposal is continued in C00101. |
Requested on: |
2002-02-26 |
Evaluated on: |
2002-05-28 |
Resolved on: |
2002-12-02 |
Withdrawn on: |
|
Evaluation closing on: |
2002-04-30 |
Validation closing on: |
2002-07-31 |