CHANGE REQUEST |
Request identity number: |
C00159 |
Applies to: |
S01844, S01845, S01855, S01856, S01857, S01858 |
Type of request: |
Technically new |
Request status level: |
Resolved |
Proposal: |
Introduce symbols for multiposition selector switches for voltage and current.
Multi-position selector (diverter) switch: switching device used in conjunction with a tap selector to carry, make or break currents in circuits which have already been selected.
Multi-position selector (diverter) switches are sometimes called arcing switches (IEC 60214-1, Ed. 1 (2003-02).
|
Reason: |
These symbols are proposed because there are no other applicable symbols in IEC 60617.
This proposal is a continuation of a part of the change request C00134. Please refer to that CR for background information. Further information obtained from the JP NC is included the attached C00159_information.pdf
|
Requested by: |
Hiromasa Yamaoka
hiromasa.yamaoka.pv@hitachi.com
JP |
General comments: |
Extended procedure: 3/933/CDV and 3/934/CDV. |
Comments at evaluation: |
Submitted for evaluation 2007-05-07.
-------------------------------------------------
DE(RESC): We do not support this CR.This Symbols could be createt by combinations of existing basic- symbols. There is no need to add new symbols to the database which are not in line with the basic symbol for a switch S00227.
AT(WGAS): No to symbols S01844, and S01845. The Symbols looks like existing Symbols with different meanings and could be mixed. For instance Symbol for lamp. The requirement for this symbols is covered by existing symbols for swtches in the database. Normal procedure.
JP(HIKE): Japanese NC believes that not only elementally graphical symbols but also symbols for the complex devices which are not represented by simple combination of existing symbols are needed.
Therefore, the proposal should be processed by nomad database procedure.
FI(ARSI): FI NC support the proposal. Normal database procedure.
CN(GUTI):Normal database procedure.
DK(KATH): Yes to the proposal, but extended procedure.
SE (TOHA): We do not support this CR.This Symbols could be createt by combinations of existing basic symbols.
NO(ES): I am doubtful to this proposal. We have in the database a number of symbols for selectors that may be used as the proposed symbols are used as shown in the attached document. The graphical layout proposed gives me an impression that here is shown the physical device to turn around on the instrument.
--------------------------------------------------
Conclusion by the Secretary 2007-08-07: The opinions are really split:
For the procedure: 1 extended; 3 normal; and 3 abstentions (no clearly expressed opinion)
For the symbols: 2 yes; 3 no and 2 abstentions
In this situation I prefer to consult the National Commitees through the extended procedure.
Document 3/858/CD was circulated 2007-08-17, closing 2007-11-16.
--------------------------------------------------
Comment by the Secretary 2007-12-11: The comments on 3/858/CD are collected in document 3/880/CC. As a result a new CD will be circulated in which the symbols S01855, S01856, S01857 and S01858 have been added.
--------------------------------------------------
Comment by the Secretary 2008-01-28: The second CD, document 3/894/CD was prepared for circulation 2008-02-15.
--------------------------------------------------
Comment by the Secretary 2008-09-17: A compliation of comments, document 3/926/CC was prepared for circulation 2008-09-19. The comments were divergating and no clear guidance on how to proceed could be obtained.
--------------------------------------------------
Comment by the Secretary 2008-10-30: At the plenary meeting of TC3 in Prague it was decided to split the content into two CDVs, in order to get a clear vote. As a result documents 3/933/CDV and 3/934/CDV were prepared and circulated simultaneously.
-------------------------------------------------- |
Comments at validation: |
Comment by Secretary 2009-06-01:
The result of the voting of the two CDV's resulted in rejection of 3/933/CDV and approval of 3/934/CDV. A FDIS will be circulated including the symbols S01855-S01858. The symbols S01844 and S01845 will get the status rejected.
----------------------------------------------
The FDIS was approved and symbols S01855-S01858 will go to standard. |
Voting at validation: |
3/951/FDIS was approved with 11 votes in favour and 1 against (see 3/959/RVD). |
Requested on: |
2007-05-07 |
Evaluated on: |
2007-08-07 |
Resolved on: |
2009-09-11 |
Withdrawn on: |
|
Evaluation closing on: |
2007-07-20 |
Validation closing on: |
2009-09-11 |