CHANGE REQUEST
Request identity number:
C00273
Applies to:
S01920
Type of request:
Technical modification
Request status level:
Resolved
Proposal:
Proposal to correct graphical symbol position
Reason:
This CR introduce new graphical symbol for photodiode which replace old S00685. Also this CR modify application note A00042 for light direction presented by arrows. Proposed new symbol is presented with variant A position and direction of arrows present light to photodiode.
During the preparation of this proposal MT 60617 was consulted
Requested by:
Hiroaki Ikeda
ikeda@faculty.chiba-u.jp
JP
General comments:
Comments at evaluation:
FI(ARSI): FI NC support this change request with normal database procedure.
FR(LROG): FR NC support this change request with normal database procedure.
SE(PASV): SE NC support this change request with normal database procedure.
NO(ES): NO NC support this change request with normal database procedure.
JP(HIKE): JP NC supports this change request with Normal Database Procedure.
AT(WGAS): There is no need for a new Symbol. The existing symbol S00685 is well known, and looks like the new proposal. AT NC does not support this CR.
DE(RESC); DE NC agrees with the comments from AT and does not support this CR
DK(KATH): DK NC support this change request with normal database procedure.
CN(GUTI): CN NC supports this change request with normal database procedure.
-------------------------------------------------
Secretary comment: The Evaluation was closed with 7 votes for normal database procedure and two votes for withdrawal. The proposal will go to validation.
Note: the proposal was initiated together with MT 60617 as a correction of S00685 for better correspondence to the rules of application. However, standardized symbols shall not be changed, but be replaced by a new symbol if required.
-------------------------------------------------
Comments at validation:
Secretaries comment: The validation was closed with five votes in favour and one against the new symbol
Symbol S01920 will be standard to replace S00685
Voting at validation:
JP(HIKE): JNC votes Yes.
FI(ARSI): FI NC votes YES.
NO(ES): NO NC votes YES
FR(LDUF): FR NC votes YES
AT(WGAS): AT NC votes NO
DK(KATH): DK NC votes YES
Requested on:
2013-06-23
Evaluated on:
2013-10-04
Resolved on:
2013-12-17
Withdrawn on:
Evaluation closing on:
2013-09-15
Validation closing on:
2013-12-06
C00273-S01920_S00685_Photodiode.rtf