CHANGE REQUEST

Request identity number:
C00275

Applies to:
S01922

Type of request:
Technically new

Request status level:
Resolved

Proposal:
Proposal to standardize graphical symbol for diagrams for concept: Transducer

Reason:
This CR introduces graphical symbols for diagrams to present concept transducer. Transducer combines concepts “sensor” and “converter”. In this concept sensor’s output signal is converted to required output form of transducer (see converter application note A00056). Graphical symbol S01921 Sensor application note A00275 is relevant also to this symbol “Symbol rectangular width can be increased for multiple letters. However angle of arrowhead shall be kept constant”.

During the preparation of this proposal MT 60617 was consulted.

Requested by:
Arto Sirvio
arto.sirvio@sesko.fi
FI

General comments:

Comments at evaluation:
FI(ARSI): FI NC support this change request with normal database procedure.
AT(WIGAS): AT NC supports S01922,normal database procedure.
JP(HIKE): JP NC supports this change request with normal database procedure together with the attached comments (memo).
SE(PASV): SE NC support this change request with normal database procedure.
FR(LDUF): FR NC supports this change request with normal database procedure.
-------------------------------------------------
Secretary comment: The Evaluation was closed with 5 votes for normal database procedure. The proposal will go to validation. The JP comment will be considered.
-------------------------------------------------

Comments at validation:
JP(HIKE): "The JP comment will be considered." was wriiten in above, but the graphics under validation had not been improved.
What is the relationship between S01061 and S01922 under validation?
Linked A00275 seems irrelevant or erroniously linked.

AT(WGAS): AT NC supports S01922, no comments.

DK(KATH): A00275 is a mistake shall be written A00375.

JP(HIKE): Process needs to be restarted from the evaluation stage.
-------------------------------------------------
Secretaries comment: The validation was closed with five votes in favour and one against the new symbol. Some corrections was required in evaluation and validation (see editorial changes in C00277). Symbol S01922 will be standard.

Voting at validation:
DK(KATH): DK NC vote yes with an editorial comment
NO(ES): NO NC vote yes
JP(HIKE): JP NC votes No because of the above mentioned reason.
FI(ARSI): FI NC votes Yes
AT(WGAS): AT NC votes Yes
SE (PASV): SE NC votes yes

Requested on:
2014-07-24

Evaluated on:
2014-10-01

Resolved on:
2015-02-09

Withdrawn on:

Evaluation closing on:
2014-09-30

Validation closing on:
2014-12-01
File Attachment Icon
S01923_memo_20140727.doc		File Attachment Icon
CR_IEC60617-S01922_Transducer.docx